How Much Extra Protein Do You Really Need to Build Muscle?

Written by

in

In my opinion, far less than you might think.

NOTE: I am not a medical professional and nothing in this post or on this blog is medical advice. This blog is for educational purposes only. Always speak to a qualified medical professional before making any lifestyle or dietary changes.

Since protein is the building block of muscle tissue, most assume that if you want to build lots of muscle, you should be eating significantly more protein than the average person. On the surface, this makes sense, but it forgets one thing: the process of muscle growth in natural lifters is super, super slow.

Let’s look at this practically: it is generally agreed on that to build twenty pounds of muscle in a year as a natural lifter is absolutely stellar progress, certainly near the upper limit of what’s possible. Twenty pounds is roughly 9072 grams. Muscle is, by weight, only about 20% protein. That means that of those 9072g, only about 1814 of them are made of actual protein (with most of the rest being water). If we then divide this number by the 365 days in a year, we end up with 5g/day. This means that, in theory, in order to build 20lbs of muscle in a year, you would, on average, need to eat approximately 5 extra grams of protein per day.

Now, it’s true that things such as bioavailability are also relevant here; I don’t deny that. But even if we assume that only half the extra protein you eat actually reaches its intended target, this would mean that building muscle at nearly maximum speed as a natural lifter would require eating only 10 extra grams of protein per day (by which I mean 10g per day above what would be needed to stay healthy). A resistance training workout typically doesn’t result in a huge amount of muscle and tissue damage needing repair (though it does result in some). Thus, I find it hard to believe that all the extra protein lifters are told they need in order to make gains is really necessary.

To be clear, I’m not saying that you shouldn’t eat more protein than this, or that doing so will hurt your progress. I’m simply explaining why I think the huge emphasis on protein is misplaced in the world of natural lifting. This is partly why I eat a low-protein diet (and built my physique on it).

Jeremy Ethier. (2025, October 5). You’re Wasting Your Money On Protein (NEW RESEARCH) [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1bx0GMofYw