Category: Aesthetics

  • Excessive Leanness: Physique Killer

    Many believe a super lean physique looks better than a moderately lean one. Are they right?

    Most people agree that having too much muscle (especially amounts you can only get from serious use of substances) looks bad, but there is a more widely accepted goal that is also extreme: being shredded.

    The constant push for extremes, both in terms of muscle mass and leanness, has come at the cost of aesthetics and quality of life. Some lifters walk around perpetually hungry, lethargic and miserable to maintain this look. I think one reason this is so sought after is because we live in a society where being overweight is the norm, and thus, being extremely lean is a way to distinguish oneself from the masses. That may be true, but I think we should first stop and consider whether this actually looks good.

    In my opinion, physiques like Christian Bale’s in Batman Begins prove definitively that while sufficient leanness is important, there is a point where more is not better; would he have looked better with lower body fat? I doubt it, and if you’re already lean, odds are you won’t either.

    Jeff Nippard. (2022, August 24). The Ugly Truth About Getting Shredded (Science Explained) [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=larBqTjA7-g

  • Is a V-Taper Necessary?

    Some features bodybuilders chase aren’t really necessary for a great physique.

    Everyone knows that the number-one feature a bodybuilder should pursue is a V-taper… right? In reality, while a pronounced V-taper looks great, I’ve never seen a lean, muscular physique that looked worse simply because it didn’t have a V-taper. Many Bronze-Era bodybuilders, such as Otto Arco, did not emphasize a large shoulder-to-waist ratio, nor do many jacked Olympic weightlifters. Do their physiques look worse for it?

    Similarly, we are taught that the worst thing that can happen to a physique is a muscle imbalance: that is, having some muscles noticeably more developed than others. While this rule of thumb definitely has more validity than the previous one (a severe imbalance of the wrong kind can unquestionably look bad), it is far from absolute. Returning to the examples of the Bronze-Era bodybuilders, we find that many of them had very little chest development compared to their other muscle groups (arms, delts, etc.). I must ask again: did this make their physiques ugly? In my opinion, certainly not. In fact, I am somewhat partial to the appearance of smaller pecs compared to the rest of the physique (though a larger chest certainly looks good also). Some imbalances are certainly unaesthetic, and avoiding imbalances is a safe strategy, but this certainly isn’t an absolute rule.

    I want to promote the concept that lifters should give themselves some freedom to develop their proportions as they desire, rather than doing so as dictated by another’s opinion. My advice is to monitor your physique to ensure the proportions are moving in a direction you like, and when in doubt, to simply give equal attention to all muscle groups.

    Bony to Beastly. (2025, January 25). The V-Taper Physique Myth [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5S1wtcspDCc

  • What Does “Bodybuilding” Actually Mean?

    There are two primary schools of thought.

    Many would say bodybuilding is the practice of maximizing both leanness and muscle mass. Others believe it is the pursuit of an aesthetic physique. While these may sound the same, there is a difference: just because a physique is leaner or carries more muscle mass does not necessarily mean it is more aesthetic. For example, most people would agree that “mass monsters” are less aesthetic than Henry Cavill in Man of Steel.

    From what I can tell, the concept of bodybuilding as the process of getting as big and lean as possible is a more recent concept. The earliest bodybuilders valued aesthetics above dramatic muscle mass and body fat levels. Eugen Sandow, one of the first prominent bodybuilders, explicitly tried to replicate the proportions of classical statues.

    In short, the word “bodybuilding” can have two different meanings. Personally, I am interested in the aesthetic version, and I believe it is the abandonment of this standard that has led us from the elegant physiques of the past to the mass monster era we are currently in.

    Further reading:

    Eugen Sandow: Part 1 – The Perfect Male Form. Wolf and Iron. https://wolfandiron.com/blogs/feedthewolf/eugen-sandow-part-1-the-perfect-male-form?srsltid=AU7gw4VQMyJXzt5LsyL8Gd_Jmm26djWnbUNeDvxrB-zQ_gzyXq_p-275>